But when Flood follows up with, “Please don’t tell me her name is Katie Marie,” it’s revealed that she and Maloney also have the same middle name. (Awkward!)

Despite the unbelievable coincidence, Schwartz takes the revelation in stride. “Katie Marie? You gotta do it to me,” he reacts in a confessional. “This is the universe f–king with me. It’s a good joke though.”

Winter House airs Tuesdays at 9 p.m. on Bravo. And keep reading to learn more about season three.